Proportionality and Compromises

Zanetti V (2020)
Journal of Moral Philosophy 17(1): 75-97.

Zeitschriftenaufsatz | Veröffentlicht | Englisch
 
Download
Es wurde kein Volltext hochgeladen. Nur Publikationsnachweis!
Abstract / Bemerkung
When individual rights, especially constitutional rights, compete with other rights or with a public good, judges and politicians involved in the legislative process or jurisdictional process are expected to balance their decision in such a way that the gain from achieving the goal mitigates the costs of the resulting loss for the parties. Jurists speak of the doctrine of proportionality in connection with this process of balancing.In the proportionality calculus, judges have to evaluate whether the impact on individual rights outweighs the public purpose pursued through a state’s legal activity. I will argue that the procedure of proportionality is similar to the procedure of reaching a compromise. More precisely, I will defend that compromise is a special case of the principle of proportionality, for it applies when claims cannot be balanced or in the absence of an overarching principle on which all the parties agree. With this, I aim to show the connection between the principle of proportionality and compromises without conflating these two concepts, and to offer new perspectives on the discussion of proportionality as it is used in the legal context.
Stichworte
Philosophy
Erscheinungsjahr
2020
Zeitschriftentitel
Journal of Moral Philosophy
Band
17
Ausgabe
1
Seite(n)
75-97
ISSN
1740-4681
eISSN
1745-5243
Page URI
https://pub.uni-bielefeld.de/record/2943341

Zitieren

Zanetti V. Proportionality and Compromises. Journal of Moral Philosophy. 2020;17(1):75-97.
Zanetti, V. (2020). Proportionality and Compromises. Journal of Moral Philosophy, 17(1), 75-97. doi:10.1163/17455243-20182843
Zanetti, V. (2020). Proportionality and Compromises. Journal of Moral Philosophy 17, 75-97.
Zanetti, V., 2020. Proportionality and Compromises. Journal of Moral Philosophy, 17(1), p 75-97.
V. Zanetti, “Proportionality and Compromises”, Journal of Moral Philosophy, vol. 17, 2020, pp. 75-97.
Zanetti, V.: Proportionality and Compromises. Journal of Moral Philosophy. 17, 75-97 (2020).
Zanetti, Véronique. “Proportionality and Compromises”. Journal of Moral Philosophy 17.1 (2020): 75-97.