Genetic Determinism and the Innate-Acquired Distinction in Medicine

Kronfeldner M (2009)
Medicine Studies 1(2): 167-181.

Zeitschriftenaufsatz | Veröffentlicht | Englisch
Abstract / Bemerkung
This article illustrates in which sense genetic determinism is still part of the contemporary interactionist consensus in medicine. Three dimensions of this consensus are discussed: kinds of causes, a continuum of traits ranging from monogenetic diseases to car accidents, and different kinds of determination due to different norms of reaction. On this basis, this article explicates in which sense the interactionist consensus presupposes the innate?acquired distinction. After a descriptive Part 1, Part 2 reviews why the innate?acquired distinction is under attack in contemporary philosophy of biology. Three arguments are then presented to provide a limited and pragmatic defense of the distinction: an epistemic, a conceptual, and a historical argument. If interpreted in a certain manner, and if the pragmatic goals of prevention and treatment (ideally specifying what medicine and health care is all about) are taken into account, then the innate?acquired distinction can be a useful epistemic tool. It can help, first, to understand that genetic determination does not mean fatalism, and, second, to maintain a system of checks and balances in the continuing nature?nurture debates.
Medicine; Genetic disease; Innate-acquired distinction; Genetic determinism; Geneticization
Medicine Studies
Page URI


Kronfeldner M. Genetic Determinism and the Innate-Acquired Distinction in Medicine. Medicine Studies. 2009;1(2):167-181.
Kronfeldner, M. (2009). Genetic Determinism and the Innate-Acquired Distinction in Medicine. Medicine Studies, 1(2), 167-181.
Kronfeldner, M. (2009). Genetic Determinism and the Innate-Acquired Distinction in Medicine. Medicine Studies 1, 167-181.
Kronfeldner, M., 2009. Genetic Determinism and the Innate-Acquired Distinction in Medicine. Medicine Studies, 1(2), p 167-181.
M. Kronfeldner, “Genetic Determinism and the Innate-Acquired Distinction in Medicine”, Medicine Studies, vol. 1, 2009, pp. 167-181.
Kronfeldner, M.: Genetic Determinism and the Innate-Acquired Distinction in Medicine. Medicine Studies. 1, 167-181 (2009).
Kronfeldner, Maria. “Genetic Determinism and the Innate-Acquired Distinction in Medicine”. Medicine Studies 1.2 (2009): 167-181.
Alle Dateien verfügbar unter der/den folgenden Lizenz(en):
Copyright Statement:
Dieses Objekt ist durch das Urheberrecht und/oder verwandte Schutzrechte geschützt. [...]
Access Level
OA Open Access
Zuletzt Hochgeladen
MD5 Prüfsumme

1 Zitation in Europe PMC

Daten bereitgestellt von Europe PubMed Central.

Genes, body clocks and prevention of sleep problems.
Nordgren A., Med Health Care Philos 19(4), 2016
PMID: 27053223

40 References

Daten bereitgestellt von Europe PubMed Central.

Innateness is canalization: In defense of a developmental account of innateness
Ariew Andre., 1999
Can the norm of reaction save the gene concept?
Falk Raphael., 2001

Fausto-Sterling Anne., 2000

Fukuyama Francis., 2002
What’s in a cause? The pragmatic dimensions of genetic explanations
Gannett Lisa., 1999


Gilbert ScottF, Epel David., 2009
Schizophrenia and the narrative of enlightened geneticization.
Hedgecoe A., Soc Stud Sci 31(6), 2001
PMID: 11831294

Hogben Lancelot., 1933

Jablonka Eva, Lamb Marion., 1995
The persistence of dichotomies in the study of behavioral development
Johnston TimothyD., 1987

Kaplan Jonathan., 2000

Kitcher Philip., 1996
Battling the undead: How and (how not) to resist genetic determinism
Kitcher Philip., 2003
The Superorganic
Kroeber AlfredL., 1917
If there is nothing beyond the organic …: Heredity and culture at the boundaries of anthropology in the work of Alfred L. Kroeber
Kronfeldner MariaE., 2009
Semantic and conceptual issues in the nature-nurture problem
Lehrman DanielS., 1970
Mutationen des Gendiskurses: Der genetische Determinismus nach dem Humangenomprojekt
Lemke Thomas., 2007
The analysis of variance and the analysis of causes
Lewontin RichardC., 1985

Lewontin RichardC, Rose StevenP, Kamin LeonJ., 1984
Phenylketonuria and the rise of public health genetics
Lindee Susan., 2006
Hereditary or acquired disease? Early nineteenth century debates on the cause of infantile scrofula and tuberculosis
Lomax Elizabeth., 1977
The medical origins of heredity
López-Beltrán Carlos., 2007
Innateness and the sciences
Mameli Matteo, Bateson Patrick., 2006

Constitutional and hereditary disorders
Olby RobertC., 1993

Oyama Susan., 1985

Oyama Susan., 2000
Terms in tension: What do you do when all the good words are taken?
Oyama Susan., 2001

Behavior: Its nature and nurture
Schaffner KennethF., 2006

Skinner BurrhusF., 1948

Skyrms Brian., 2000
The idea of innateness
Stich StephenP., 1975
Apportioning causal responsibility
Sober Elliott., 1988
Innateness as an explanatory concept
Wendler Dave., 1996
Developmental constraints, generative entrenchment and the innate–acquired distinction
Wimsatt William., 1986
Generative entrenchment, evolution, and innateness: Philosophy, evolutionary biology, and conceptual foundations of science
Wimsatt William., 1999
Causes that make a difference
Waters KennethC., 2007
Identical mutations and phenotypic variation.
Wolf U., Hum. Genet. 100(3-4), 1997
PMID: 9272148


Markieren/ Markierung löschen
Markierte Publikationen

Open Data PUB


PMID: 20234831
PubMed | Europe PMC

Suchen in

Google Scholar