Risk-based governance against national obstacles? Comparative dynamics of Europeanization in Dutch, French, and German flooding policies

Paul R, Bouder F, Wesseling M (2016)
JOURNAL OF RISK RESEARCH 19(8: SI): 1043-1062.

Download
Es wurde kein Volltext hochgeladen. Nur Publikationsnachweis!
Zeitschriftenaufsatz | Veröffentlicht | Englisch
Autor
; ;
Abstract / Bemerkung
Comparative studies have recently highlighted obstacles related to continental European countries' proclivity for adopting risk-based governance. However, so far, the interface between risk-based policy-making in the EU and potential policy change in reluctant member states has been underexplored. We compare flooding policies in the Netherlands with those in France and Germany to establish the extent to and conditions under which EU-level risk-based policies can transform national governance approaches. Drawing on the concept of Europeanization, we compare national adaptation pressures stemming from the EU floods directive, investigate adaptation dynamics, and account for transformations towards risk-based thinking. We find that Europeanization enabled a mainstreaming of risk-based flooding policies in France and Germany, as national actors used the EU as a venue to entice a desired policy rationalization and centralization. By contrast, and somewhat unexpectedly, the Netherlands partially retrenched from EU procedures because the directive's reporting mechanisms were considered to breach The Hague's aspirational policy approach. Overall, the paper identifies a strong potential for even soft' EU policies to ease national reluctance to risk-based governance approaches, but it also indicates limits where member states use risk-based techniques within an aspirational protection framework.
Erscheinungsjahr
Zeitschriftentitel
JOURNAL OF RISK RESEARCH
Band
19
Zeitschriftennummer
8: SI
Seite
1043-1062
ISSN
eISSN
PUB-ID

Zitieren

Paul R, Bouder F, Wesseling M. Risk-based governance against national obstacles? Comparative dynamics of Europeanization in Dutch, French, and German flooding policies. JOURNAL OF RISK RESEARCH. 2016;19(8: SI):1043-1062.
Paul, R., Bouder, F., & Wesseling, M. (2016). Risk-based governance against national obstacles? Comparative dynamics of Europeanization in Dutch, French, and German flooding policies. JOURNAL OF RISK RESEARCH, 19(8: SI), 1043-1062.
Paul, R., Bouder, F., and Wesseling, M. (2016). Risk-based governance against national obstacles? Comparative dynamics of Europeanization in Dutch, French, and German flooding policies. JOURNAL OF RISK RESEARCH 19, 1043-1062.
Paul, R., Bouder, F., & Wesseling, M., 2016. Risk-based governance against national obstacles? Comparative dynamics of Europeanization in Dutch, French, and German flooding policies. JOURNAL OF RISK RESEARCH, 19(8: SI), p 1043-1062.
R. Paul, F. Bouder, and M. Wesseling, “Risk-based governance against national obstacles? Comparative dynamics of Europeanization in Dutch, French, and German flooding policies”, JOURNAL OF RISK RESEARCH, vol. 19, 2016, pp. 1043-1062.
Paul, R., Bouder, F., Wesseling, M.: Risk-based governance against national obstacles? Comparative dynamics of Europeanization in Dutch, French, and German flooding policies. JOURNAL OF RISK RESEARCH. 19, 1043-1062 (2016).
Paul, Regine, Bouder, Frederic, and Wesseling, Mara. “Risk-based governance against national obstacles? Comparative dynamics of Europeanization in Dutch, French, and German flooding policies”. JOURNAL OF RISK RESEARCH 19.8: SI (2016): 1043-1062.