The dialectics of infinitism and coherentism: inferential justification versus holism and coherence

Herzberg F (2014)
Synthese 191(4): 701-723.

Download
Es wurde kein Volltext hochgeladen. Nur Publikationsnachweis!
Zeitschriftenaufsatz | Veröffentlicht | Englisch
Abstract / Bemerkung
This paper formally explores the common ground between mild versions of epistemological coherentism and infinitism; it proposes-and argues for-a hybrid, coherentist-infinitist account of epistemic justification. First, the epistemological regress argument and its relation to the classical taxonomy regarding epistemic justification-of foundationalism, infinitism and coherentism-is reviewed. We then recall recent results proving that an influential argument against infinite regresses of justification, which alleges their incoherence on account of probabilistic inconsistency, cannot be maintained. Furthermore, we prove that the Principle of Inferential Justification has rather unwelcome consequences-formally resembling the Sorites paradox-as soon as it is iterated and combined with a natural Bayesian perspective on probabilistic inferences. We conclude that strong versions of foundationalism and infinitism should be abandoned. Positively, we provide a rough sketch for a graded formal coherence notion, according to which infinite regresses of epistemic justification will often have more than a minimal degree of coherence.
Erscheinungsjahr
Zeitschriftentitel
Synthese
Band
191
Zeitschriftennummer
4
Seite
701-723
ISSN
eISSN
PUB-ID

Zitieren

Herzberg F. The dialectics of infinitism and coherentism: inferential justification versus holism and coherence. Synthese. 2014;191(4):701-723.
Herzberg, F. (2014). The dialectics of infinitism and coherentism: inferential justification versus holism and coherence. Synthese, 191(4), 701-723. doi:10.1007/s11229-013-0273-5
Herzberg, F. (2014). The dialectics of infinitism and coherentism: inferential justification versus holism and coherence. Synthese 191, 701-723.
Herzberg, F., 2014. The dialectics of infinitism and coherentism: inferential justification versus holism and coherence. Synthese, 191(4), p 701-723.
F. Herzberg, “The dialectics of infinitism and coherentism: inferential justification versus holism and coherence”, Synthese, vol. 191, 2014, pp. 701-723.
Herzberg, F.: The dialectics of infinitism and coherentism: inferential justification versus holism and coherence. Synthese. 191, 701-723 (2014).
Herzberg, Frederik. “The dialectics of infinitism and coherentism: inferential justification versus holism and coherence”. Synthese 191.4 (2014): 701-723.